Case Studies
An Attorney Proposed A $325,000 Spend Down. A Second Opinion Changed Everything.
When Janet required skilled nursing care at approximately $17,250 per month, Peter sought a second opinion before committing to an attorney’s proposed $325,000 spend down. Stronghold Financial reviewed the couple’s care costs, assets and Peter’s future financial needs, then developed a structured-income strategy. Their case reports approximately $650,000 in Assets protected and approximately $855 per month out of pocket after ALTCS. Their outcome reflects their individual circumstances.
Expert context: Katie Brenneman, Founder of Stronghold Financial.
Last updated: .
Care and financial facts
Care Situation: Skilled Nursing Care. Monthly care cost: ~$17,250/mo. Countable Assets: ~$643,366. Attorney's Proposed Spend Down: ~$325,000. Assets protected: ~$650,000. Monthly out-of-pocket after ALTCS: ~$855/mo. 5-year savings: ~$983,700.
The family’s starting question
When Janet required skilled nursing care, Peter had already sought professional advice.
An elder law attorney proposed a strategy — but Peter would still need to spend approximately $325,000, and Janet would still owe approximately $4,500 per month in ongoing costs.
Peter wasn't looking for a shortcut. He simply wanted to be certain he understood all of his options before making irreversible financial decisions.
This is the story of what happened when he sought a second opinion.
The Day The Numbers Stopped Making Sense
When Janet's health declined to the point that she required skilled nursing care, Peter found himself confronting questions he never expected to face.
Like many couples, they had spent decades doing the things responsible people are told to do. They worked hard. Saved consistently. Built investment accounts. Maintained emergency reserves. Prepared for retirement. And assumed those resources would provide security later in life.
Then a medical crisis changed everything.
At first, Peter focused entirely on Janet — the doctors, the hospitalizations, the specialists, the treatments, the care decisions. But eventually another reality became impossible to ignore.
The cost. Because this wasn't assisted living. It wasn't memory care. Janet required a significantly higher level of care. And the estimated cost was approximately $17,250 every month — more than $200,000 every year.
The medical crisis was overwhelming. The financial reality felt just as overwhelming.
The Question Every Spouse Eventually Asks
At first, Peter focused on surviving the next month. Then the next. Then the next. Like many spouses, he eventually found himself asking a question that had nothing to do with medicine.
How long can we keep doing this?
That's when the financial crisis began. Because long-term care is rarely about the first month. Most families can find a way to survive the first month. The challenge is the uncertainty.
No one could tell Peter whether Janet would need care for six months, three years, five years, ten years, or longer. And every additional month carried another substantial bill.
The more Peter thought about it, the more one question kept returning: What happens if this lasts much longer than anyone expects? Because at more than $17,000 per month, the financial consequences could become enormous.
The Healthy Spouse Dilemma
One of the most overlooked aspects of long-term care planning is the healthy spouse. Everyone focuses on the person receiving care. That's understandable. But there is another person whose future is affected by every decision.
Peter still needed a place to live. He still needed income. He still needed retirement security. He still needed protection against future emergencies. He still needed a plan if he someday required care himself.
Peter wasn't worried about becoming wealthy. He was worried about becoming vulnerable — vulnerable to future healthcare costs, market downturns, needing care himself, and outliving his savings.
Like many healthy spouses, Peter wasn't trying to avoid paying for Janet's care. He simply didn't want to create a second crisis while trying to solve the first one.
The Shocking Calculation
When the family's assets were reviewed, the total countable assets were approximately $643,366 — investment accounts, bank accounts, life insurance cash values, vehicles, and other countable resources.
At first glance, many people would assume that having more than $600,000 means a family is financially secure. Peter quickly learned that long-term care planning doesn't always work that way.
After applying the applicable ALTCS resource calculations, the projected spend down amount was approximately $492,746. Nearly half a million dollars.
He and Janet had spent decades building financial security. Yet it seemed like the reward for responsible planning was being told to spend through much of what they had worked so hard to accumulate.
The Choice He Thought He Had
At first, Peter believed there were only two options.
Spend approximately $492,746 on care. Reduce assets. Eventually qualify for benefits.
Continue paying privately and hope the money lasted.
Neither option felt particularly appealing. Because once almost half a million dollars is spent, it doesn't come back. That money represented years of work, years of saving, years of sacrifice, and years of planning.
Many Arizona families reach this exact same conclusion. And many never realize there may be other options worth exploring.
The Second Opinion That Changed Everything
What made Peter's situation especially frustrating was that he had already sought professional advice. An elder law attorney specializing in ALTCS had proposed a strategy designed to help Janet qualify for benefits. Under that recommendation, Peter would still need to spend approximately $325,000 — and even after spending those assets, Janet would still be responsible for approximately $4,500 per month in ongoing out-of-pocket care costs.
Peter wasn't looking for a different answer. He simply wanted to be certain he understood all of his options before making irreversible financial decisions.
As Janet's skilled nursing facility helped the family navigate next steps, staff encouraged Peter to seek a second opinion before committing to a strategy. That conversation led him to Stronghold.
The Second Review Revealed:
✓ Instead of spending $325,000 — a different strategy was developed
✓ Instead of preserving only a portion — approximately $650,000 was protected
✓ Instead of $4,500/month ongoing costs — reduced to approximately $855/month
The difference was substantial. Not because the attorney had done anything wrong — but because different professionals often evaluate different pieces of the puzzle. The attorney had focused on legal planning. The second review focused on long-term care eligibility, healthy spouse protection, and the interaction between assets, income, and ALTCS rules.
The Concept Most Families Have Never Heard
One of the most important discussions involved understanding how ALTCS evaluates resources. Many families assume assets can only be handled one way — they believe the only path to eligibility is spending countable assets until they reach required limits. In some situations, that may be true. But not always.
One of the most misunderstood aspects of ALTCS planning is that the same dollars generally cannot be treated as both a countable asset and income at the same time.
That distinction matters. Because if countable assets are converted into a structured income stream that complies with ALTCS requirements, those dollars may be evaluated differently for eligibility purposes. The funds don't disappear. They aren't simply given away. And they aren't consumed by care expenses. Instead, they can be repositioned in a manner that complies with program requirements while helping protect the healthy spouse.
Peter was surprised to learn there could be another way to evaluate the situation.
From Spend Down To Structured Income
Rather than spending approximately $492,746 on care, the proposed strategy involved repositioning those funds into an ALTCS-compliant structured income stream. The structured income stream would be issued in Peter's name. The funds would not disappear. They would not be consumed by care costs. Instead, they would be returned to Peter over time.
~$10,056/month
Projected structured income for 49 months — returned to Peter
That distinction changed everything. Because Peter wasn't choosing between keeping the money and losing the money. He was choosing between spending the money and converting it into income for himself. Once he understood that distinction, the situation looked very different.
What If He Had Never Learned His Options?
One of the most powerful parts of Peter's story is imagining what might have happened if he never sought another opinion. What if he simply accepted the spend down calculation? What if he spent nearly half a million dollars first? What if he assumed there was no alternative?
No one can know exactly how the future would have unfolded. But one thing is certain — the financial outcome would have looked very different. Because once those assets were spent, they would no longer be available to support Peter's future. They would no longer be available to help protect him if he experienced his own health challenges. And they would no longer provide the financial security he had spent a lifetime building.
That's why timing matters. The earlier families understand their options, the more opportunities they typically have.
The Outcome
The outcome changed everything.
Peter preserved approximately $650,000
Peter avoided a proposed $325,000 spend down
Janet received the skilled nursing care she needed
Peter's monthly out-of-pocket obligation was reduced from approximately $4,500 to approximately $855
Assets were repositioned into a structured income stream designed to benefit him
Peter finally had a roadmap — and a sense of hope
For the first time since the crisis began, Peter understood what came next. More importantly, he understood that caring for Janet didn't necessarily require sacrificing everything they had spent decades building.
What This Story Means For Other Arizona Families
Peter and Janet's story highlights several realities many families never learn.
Many people assume spend down is their only option.
Many healthy spouses worry about losing everything they worked their entire lives to build.
Many families make irreversible financial decisions before fully understanding their choices.
And many never realize there may be alternatives worth exploring.
Sometimes spend down is necessary. Sometimes it isn't. The key is understanding your options before making major financial decisions. Because once assets have been spent, they generally cannot be recovered.
Professional testimonial
I regularly refer clients to Stronghold when complex ALTCS planning is involved. Their understanding of the intersection between elder law and long-term care planning is exceptional, and my clients consistently report feeling well-informed and well-served.
— Andrew Smith, Estate Planning Attorney
Privacy and individual results
Names and identifying details have been changed to protect client privacy. Results vary based on individual circumstances. Every family's situation is unique.
Expert context
Expert context: Katie Brenneman, Founder of Stronghold Financial, helps Arizona families understand ALTCS and long-term care planning. This information is educational; individual care needs and eligibility require separate evaluation.
Last updated: November 6, 2026
What Is An ALTCS Spend Down?
A spend down is the process of reducing countable assets to levels required for eligibility. Many families assume spending those assets on care is their only path to qualifying for benefits.
Do Families Always Have To Spend Down Their Assets Before Qualifying For ALTCS?
Not necessarily. Every situation is unique. Asset types, marital status, income, timing, and other factors can significantly affect planning opportunities.
Can The Healthy Spouse Preserve Assets?
Protecting the healthy spouse is often one of the most important goals of long-term care planning. The spouse who remains at home still needs income, retirement security, and resources for future needs.
What Is A Structured Income Strategy?
In some situations, countable assets can be repositioned into an ALTCS-compliant structured income stream. Because ALTCS generally cannot treat the same dollars as both a countable asset and income simultaneously, this may create planning opportunities for certain families.
Related resources
Next step
Explore Stronghold’s educational resources or schedule a complimentary consultation to understand the appropriate next step for your family.