Case Studies

How One Arizona Wife Evaluated Two Long-Term Care Strategies And Found A Potential $700,000 Difference

Barb and Fred could afford Fred’s assisted-living care at approximately $5,000 per month, but Barb wanted to understand the long-term effect on their retirement security. Stronghold Financial compared private pay with an ALTCS strategy using her financial advisor’s assumptions. The analysis showed a projected advantage exceeding $700,000 over ten years, while also showing that private pay could be better if Fred passed away early. These projections were not guarantees.

Expert context: Katie Brenneman, Founder of Stronghold Financial.

Last updated: .

Care and financial facts

Care Setting: Assisted Living. Monthly care cost: ~$5,000/mo. Assets protected: ~$810,000. Monthly out-of-pocket after ALTCS: $1,979/mo. 10-Year Advantage: $700,000+.

The family’s starting question

When Fred needed long-term care, Barb wasn't worried about qualifying for ALTCS.

She was worried about making the wrong financial decision.

Should she continue paying privately and keep her investments growing?

Or should she implement a strategy that reduced investment earnings today in exchange for potentially protecting hundreds of thousands of dollars in the future?

This is the story of how one Arizona family discovered that the biggest financial risk wasn't necessarily the one they could see.

"The earlier families understand their options, the more opportunities they typically have."

What Barb Discovered

Multiple scenarios were evaluated using her financial advisor's own assumptions

Projected 10-year advantage exceeded $700,000

Potential advantage exceeded $1 million under certain market conditions

Her own financial advisor concluded: "I can't in good conscience tell you not to do this"

Barb gained clarity, confidence, and perspective to make an informed decision

This Wasn't A Crisis

Most families contact us during a crisis. Someone is being discharged from rehabilitation. A spouse suddenly needs memory care. Medicare coverage is ending. The family is running out of money.

That wasn't Barb's situation.

Fred was already receiving the care he needed. The monthly cost was approximately $5,000. The couple had accumulated approximately $810,000 through years of hard work, disciplined saving, and thoughtful investing.

From the outside, everything appeared stable. They weren't out of money. They weren't facing an emergency. And nobody was forcing them to make a decision immediately.

Many people would have looked at their situation and concluded there was no reason to do anything. After all, they could afford the care. The bills were being paid. The investments were growing. Everything seemed fine.

But Barb wasn't focused on today. She was focused on what might happen tomorrow. And the day after that. And the year after that. Because one question kept coming back.

As she worked through those concerns, Barb discussed the situation with her estate planning attorney. Recognizing that the financial implications of long-term care extended well beyond legal documents alone, he suggested she speak with Stronghold for a second opinion on the long-term financial consequences of the decisions she was considering.

What happens if Fred needs care for a very long time?

The Question Most Families Never Ask

When long-term care enters the picture, most families ask: "Can we afford this?" It's a reasonable question. But it's often the wrong question.

The better question is: "What happens if this continues for five years? Or ten years? Or longer?"

Nobody could tell Barb how long Fred would need care. Nobody could predict future healthcare costs. Nobody could guarantee what investment markets would do. The monthly bill seemed manageable. The uncertainty did not.

Every year of care would require additional withdrawals. Additional expenses. Additional pressure on the retirement assets they had spent decades building. The longer Fred lived, the more important the decision became.

And Barb knew she needed answers before she could make an informed choice.

The Advice That Made Perfect Sense

Barb had a trusted financial advisor. He had managed the family's investments for years. He understood their goals, their risk tolerance, and had helped them build substantial financial security.

His projections assumed approximately 6% annual investment growth. From his perspective, continuing to pay privately appeared reasonable. The portfolio was growing. The family had significant assets. There was no immediate financial emergency.

On the surface, everything seemed straightforward. Why create a tax bill? Why reposition assets? Why change a strategy that appeared to be working?

Those were fair questions. In fact, they were exactly the questions Barb was asking herself.

The Questions That Kept Her Up At Night

Barb wasn't looking for someone to convince her to do anything. She wasn't looking for a sales pitch. She wanted real answers.

"Is this worth the tax cost?" — The proposed strategy would require repositioning assets, creating a significant taxable event.

"What about the investment growth I'm giving up?" — Would she lose years of market growth by repositioning assets?

"What happens if Fred dies in the first year?" — If she implemented the strategy and Fred passed away shortly afterward, would she regret it?

"What happens if he lives?" — What if care was needed for years? What if he survived much longer than expected?

Those were the questions Barb needed answered before she could make a decision.

Stopping The Guesswork

Instead of debating opinions, we decided to compare outcomes. Using the financial advisor's own assumptions, we modeled multiple scenarios.

One scenario assumed Barb continued paying privately — assets remained invested, portfolio continued earning approximately 6% annually. A second scenario assumed implementation of a structured income strategy designed to comply with ALTCS requirements.

The goal wasn't to prove one side right. The goal was to evaluate both paths objectively. Same family. Same advisor. Same assumptions. Same projected rate of return. Different strategy.

The question wasn't which strategy sounded better. The question was which strategy produced the better long-term outcome.

Understanding The Strategy

One of the most misunderstood aspects of ALTCS planning is that the same dollars generally cannot be treated as both a countable asset and income at the same time. That distinction became central to Barb's analysis.

By repositioning a portion of the countable assets into a structured income stream that complied with ALTCS requirements, those assets were no longer being evaluated the same way for eligibility purposes.

At the same time, the funds weren't disappearing. They were being returned to Barb through structured monthly payments over a relatively short period. As those payments were received, the projections assumed they would be reinvested and continue earning the same 6% annual return used by her financial advisor.

This wasn't a comparison between keeping money and losing money. It was a comparison between two different ways of deploying the same dollars. Once Barb understood that distinction, the conversation became much more meaningful.

What If Fred Died Early?

The results were surprising. If Fred passed away during the first year, continuing to pay privately actually produced the better financial outcome. Barb could potentially have approximately $100,000 more under that scenario.

That mattered. Because good planning isn't about pretending one option wins every time. It's about understanding tradeoffs.

Barb appreciated hearing that. She didn't want someone telling her what she wanted to hear. She wanted the truth. And the truth was that different outcomes produced different winners.

What If Fred Lived?

Then we evaluated the other possibility. What if Fred survived much longer than expected? What if care was needed for years?

That changed everything.

As care costs continued year after year, the cumulative impact of paying privately became larger and larger. Using the financial advisor's own assumptions, the projected advantage of the ALTCS strategy exceeded $700,000 over ten years.

$700,000+: Projected 10-year advantage.

$1M+: Under certain market conditions.

The numbers surprised everyone involved. Even more striking, if a significant market correction occurred during the early years of care, the projected advantage exceeded $1 million.

Suddenly the conversation changed. The risk Barb had been focused on wasn't necessarily the largest risk anymore.

The Asymmetric Bet

At first, Barb focused on the tax bill. That was understandable. The tax liability was immediate. Visible. Certain. The potential benefits of the strategy were future possibilities.

But once the projections were complete, something became obvious. Barb wasn't evaluating two equal risks. She was evaluating an asymmetrical outcome.

If Fred Passed Away Early: ~$100,000. Potential downside of implementing the strategy.

If Fred Needed Long-Term Care: $700,000+. Projected advantage over 10 years.

For the first time, Barb realized she wasn't deciding whether to pay taxes. She was deciding which risk she wanted to accept.

The Question That Changed Everything

Once the projections were complete, we asked Barb a simple question:

"If you make the wrong decision, which wrong decision would be more financially uncomfortable for you?"

Would it be discovering ten years from now that you gave up approximately $100,000 because Fred passed away sooner than expected? Or discovering that your portfolio is worth approximately $586,000 instead of approximately $1.3 million because years of ongoing care costs created a very different outcome than you anticipated?

That question changed the conversation. Because long-term care planning isn't about predicting the future. It's about evaluating risk. And once Barb viewed the decision through that lens, she realized she wasn't choosing between a good option and a bad option. She was choosing between two possible mistakes. The question was which mistake she could live with more comfortably.

The Moment Everything Became Clear

After reviewing every scenario, Barb's financial advisor reached a conclusion she never expected. These weren't Stronghold's assumptions. They were his. His projected rates of return. His market assumptions. His financial models.

"Barb, I can't in good conscience tell you not to do this."

— Barb's financial advisor, after reviewing every projected scenario

That statement carried tremendous weight. Because it wasn't about winning an argument. It wasn't about proving anyone wrong. It was about understanding the long-term consequences of two very different paths. And once those consequences became clear, the decision became much easier.

The Healthy Spouse Question

One of the most important lessons from Barb's story has nothing to do with Fred. It has to do with Barb. Because long-term care planning isn't only about the spouse receiving care. It's also about the spouse who remains at home.

In fact, the projected $700,000 advantage wasn't really about Fred at all. Fred was already receiving the care he needed. The real beneficiary was Barb — the spouse who still needed retirement security, income, housing, emergency reserves, healthcare, and financial flexibility for the rest of her life.

The question was never simply: "Can we pay for Fred's care?" The question was: "How do we protect Barb's future too?" That's often the most important question families forget to ask.

The Outcome

More important than the strategy itself was what Barb gained from the process: clarity, confidence, and perspective. She understood the risks. She understood the tradeoffs. And she understood how dramatically different the outcomes could become over time.

Instead of making a decision based on fear, assumptions, or incomplete information, she was able to make a decision based on facts. That's what every family deserves. Not pressure. Not opinions. Not guesswork. Just a clear understanding of what each path is likely to produce.

What This Story Means For Other Arizona Families

Barb and Fred's story highlights an important reality. Just because you can afford private pay today doesn't automatically mean it's the best long-term strategy. Sometimes it is. Sometimes it isn't.

The key is understanding the consequences of each path before making a major financial decision. Because the biggest financial risk isn't always the most visible one. And sometimes the decision that initially feels uncomfortable creates the strongest long-term outcome.

The earlier families understand their options, the more opportunities they typically have.

Professional testimonial

I regularly refer clients to Stronghold when complex ALTCS planning is involved. Their understanding of the intersection between elder law and long-term care planning is exceptional, and my clients consistently report feeling well-informed and well-served.

— Andrew Smith, Estate Planning Attorney

Privacy and individual results

Names and identifying details have been changed to protect client privacy. Results vary based on individual circumstances. Every family's situation is unique. This case study is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or tax advice.

Expert context

Expert context: Katie Brenneman, Founder of Stronghold Financial, helps Arizona families understand ALTCS and long-term care planning. This information is educational; individual care needs and eligibility require separate evaluation.

Last updated: November 6, 2026

Should We Pay Privately For Long-Term Care?

Every family's circumstances are different. The goal is not to push every family toward ALTCS planning. The goal is to understand the long-term consequences of each available option before making major financial decisions.

What If My Financial Advisor Recommends Against ALTCS Planning?

Financial advisors often evaluate decisions through an investment lens. Long-term care planning requires evaluating investment performance, care costs, longevity risk, taxes, and healthy spouse protection simultaneously. A second opinion focused specifically on long-term care planning can provide a more complete picture.

Can An ALTCS Strategy Still Make Sense If We Have Significant Assets?

Many families assume substantial assets automatically eliminate planning opportunities. Every situation is unique and should be evaluated individually. Barb and Fred's story demonstrates that significant assets don't eliminate the value of a thorough analysis.

Why Does The Healthy Spouse Matter So Much?

The healthy spouse may still have decades of life ahead of them and needs retirement security, housing, income, healthcare, and protection against future uncertainty. Long-term care planning that only focuses on the spouse receiving care often misses the most important financial question.

Related resources

Next step

Explore Stronghold’s educational resources or schedule a complimentary consultation to understand the appropriate next step for your family.

Schedule a Complimentary Consultation